When gate operators fail, homeowners face a choice: repair the existing unit or replace it entirely. The right decision depends on several factors.
When Repair Makes Sense
Unit is Relatively New
- Less than 5 years old
- Still under warranty
- Modern technology
Problem is Minor
- Capacitor replacement
- Limit switch adjustment
- Remote programming
- Sensor realignment
Repair Cost is Low
General rule: Repair if cost is less than 50% of replacement.
When Replacement Makes Sense
Unit is Aging
- Over 10-15 years old
- Multiple recent repairs
- Parts becoming scarce
Major Component Failure
- Motor burned out
- Control board fried
- Gearbox failure
- Structural damage
Technology is Obsolete
- Doesn't meet current safety standards
- No smart home compatibility
- Limited access control options
Cost Comparison Example
Typical Repair Costs
- Capacitor: $150-250
- Control board: $400-700
- Motor: $500-900
- Gearbox: $600-1,000
New Operator Costs
- Residential swing: $800-1,800 installed
- Residential slide: $1,200-2,500 installed
Benefits of Replacement
- New warranty (3-5 years)
- Latest safety features
- Smart home compatibility
- Improved reliability
- Better energy efficiency
Questions to Ask
- How old is the current operator?
- Have there been previous repairs?
- Are parts still available?
- Does repair cost exceed 50% of replacement?
- Do you want features not available on current unit?
Get an Expert Opinion
Standard Gate Co provides honest assessments of repair vs. replacement. We'll recommend what's best for your situation. Call (323) 488-GATE.